ADDRESS: 7 Yishun Industrial Street 1 #03-33, North Spring, Singapore 768162 WHATSAPP: +65 9387 0979 (Jason) EMAIL: enquiry@ntlstorage.com

ADDRESS: 7 Yishun Industrial Street 1 #03-33, North Spring, Singapore 768162

WHATSAPP: +65 9387 0979 (Jason)

EMAIL: enquiry@ntlstorage.com

How Heavy Duty Racking Are Great for Bulky Items: Store More
August 6, 2024
Mezzanine Systems Explained: Types, Benefits & Installation
September 3, 2024

Longspan Shelving vs Mezzanine: Which Fits Your Warehouse?

Longspan shelving vs mezzanine is really a choice between adding shelves to the floor you have and building a second floor inside your unit. This blog will walk you through how each option compares on clear height, floor area, load per level, budget and approvals, so you can pick the right warehouse storage racks before anyone orders steel.

What is the difference between longspan shelving and a mezzanine?

Longspan shelving is a medium duty shelving system. Upright frames carry long beams with a solid deck of chipboard, steel or mesh, and people load it by hand with cartons, totes and parts. Common spans are 1,500 mm, 1,800 mm and 2,000 mm, with shelf depths of 450 mm, 600 mm or 900 mm.

A mezzanine is an intermediate floor built inside the existing building, on its own columns or on the racking below. People walk on it, goods sit on it and it is reached by a staircase, a pallet gate or a lift. In law it is building work, not furniture.

That difference drives everything else in this comparison. Shelving uses height on the floor you already have. A mezzanine creates a second floor, and with it a second set of rules on structure, fire escape and floor area.

Which one fits your warehouse?

The table sets out how the two options compare on the points that usually decide the choice.

Decision factor Longspan shelving Mezzanine floor
Clear height needed Works in any unit; about 2 m for hand picking, 3 m to 4 m with a step ladder Rarely works for storage over storage below about 5.5 m internal clear height
Floor area Uses existing floor; shelves plus picking aisles Adds new floor area; single open stair allowed only up to 60 m² per unit if all SCDF conditions are met
Load per level Typically 250 kg to 500 kg per shelf level, heavy duty up to about 800 kg Storage areas designed to 7.5 kN/m² (about 765 kg per m²) under SS EN 1991-1-1
Budget items Shelving supply and installation Steel, PE design, BCA and SCDF submissions, sprinkler and detection extension under the deck
Approvals No BCA or SCDF submission for freestanding shelving PE design, BCA structural plan approval and permit, SCDF approval and Fire Safety Certificate
Time to use Installation only, no approval wait Approval sequence first, then fabrication and installation
Lease flexibility Dismantles and moves with you Tied to the unit; modular designs can be relocated

Clear height

Longspan is sized to people, not buildings. Pickers reach the top of a 2 m bay standing, and a 3 m or 4 m run only makes sense if the top levels hold slow stock that you touch with a ladder. It fits a low B1 unit as easily as a tall warehouse.

A mezzanine has to fit two working levels plus the deck, its beams and the sprinkler clearance under it. As a working rule, units with less than about 5.5 m internal clear height rarely support storage over storage once those are subtracted. Our guide to racking for 4 metre ceiling warehouses works through the headroom budget in a typical older JTC flatted factory.

Floor area and the 60 m² threshold

SCDF’s Fire Code 2023 sets a threshold that shapes mezzanine design. Under Clause 9.8.1a.(2) for warehouse units, one open stair may serve a mezzanine only if the aggregate mezzanine area per unit is no more than 60 m², the stair is at least 1 m wide and non combustible, travel distance complies, the structure has at least 1 hour fire resistance, habitable height is within 24 m and the deck is used only for store or ancillary office. Clause 9.6.1a.(2) sets the same conditions for factory units.

A larger deck is still possible. It simply has to meet the full means of escape rules, which usually means more exits and a bigger fire protection scope. Longspan shelving adds no floor area, so none of this applies to it.

Load per level

A 500 kg rating on a 1,800 mm by 600 mm longspan shelf works out to roughly 460 kg per square metre of shelf. That covers cartons, archive boxes and spare parts, and it is rated per level at a stated span.

A storage mezzanine is designed to SS EN 1991-1-1 Category E1, which sets 7.5 kN/m² plus a 7.0 kN concentrated load. A deck quoted at 500 kg/m² is carrying about 4.9 kN/m², which may suit a light picking platform but not palletised stock. The building’s own slab and columns below also have to carry the mezzanine columns, and in older flatted factories that is often the real limit.

Budget and timeline

Longspan is priced by the bay and installed without an approval wait, so it can be in use within the lease period you are already paying for.

A mezzanine carries costs that do not show up in the steel price: the PE’s design and site supervision, the BCA and SCDF submissions, and the extension of sprinklers and detection under the new deck. The approval sequence runs before fabrication, not alongside it, so the programme is set by your QP once they have seen the building.

What approvals does each option need in Singapore?

Longspan shelving

Freestanding longspan shelving is storage equipment, so it needs no BCA structural submission and no SCDF fire safety submission. Two limits still apply.

In JTC premises, the JTC Space Submission Handbook exempts shelves and racks from plan consent only when they stay within 3.0 m high and 1.2 m wide, with gross weight within 7.5 kN/m² or the design imposed load, whichever is lower, and a clear passageway of at least 1.2 m. Anything taller or heavier goes through JTC’s plan consent before installation.

The second limit is walkways. Once shelving carries a raised walkway so people can pick from a second tier, it becomes an access platform. JTC does not exempt shelves used as access platforms, and BCA and SCDF treat a deck people walk on as a mezzanine, whatever the quotation calls it.

Mezzanine floors

A mezzanine needs a Qualified Person who is a Professional Engineer in the civil or structural discipline. The PE submits structural plans to BCA and obtains a permit before any structural work starts. The fire safety works go to SCDF, and the deck cannot be used until the Fire Safety Certificate is issued. Landlord or MCST consent, and JTC or URA clearance where floor area changes, usually come first.

The cost of skipping this is on record. On 28 January 2025 a mezzanine floor and storage racks collapsed in a warehouse unit at 11 Toa Payoh Industrial Park, trapping three people. BCA later said it had received no application for the steel platform and racking system, and SCDF found no Fire Safety Certificate. Unauthorised building works carry a fine of up to S200,000,uptotwoyears’jail,orboth,andfailingtoobtainaFireSafetyCertificatecarriesafineofuptoS10,000.

Our guide to warehouse mezzanine floors covers mezzanine types, design loads and build timelines in full, and the mezzanine floor approval process sets out each agency’s role step by step.

When does longspan shelving make more sense?

Longspan wins when the stock moves by hand and the problem is shelf space, not floor space. Carton picking, spare parts, archive boxes and ecommerce pick faces all fit its 250 kg to 500 kg per level range.

It also wins on low ceilings and short leases. A unit under about 5.5 m clear height rarely gains from a mezzanine, and shelving that can be dismantled and moved suits a lease with two or three years left. See our guide to longspan shelving in Singapore for spans, deck choices and when a tall run needs anchoring.

When is a mezzanine worth the approval process?

A mezzanine earns its cost when you need usable floor, not only more shelf. Packing benches, a stock office, returns processing or a second picking level all need somewhere to stand and work, and shelving cannot give you that.

The conditions that favour it are generous clear height, a slab that can take the column loads, a lease long enough to recover the design and approval spend, and space pressure that a larger unit would cost more to solve. Where pallet racking already sits below, a rack supported platform uses the racking uprights as the structure for the deck above.

Can you combine longspan shelving and a mezzanine?

Yes, and many units do. Longspan shelving on a mezzanine deck gives a second picking level for cartons, with pallet racking or open floor below.

Tell the PE about the shelving before the deck is designed. Loaded shelving on a deck is load the structure has to carry, and a deck designed for foot traffic and light cartons may not take a full run of 500 kg shelf levels. Sprinkler coverage also has to reach the shelving on the upper level.

Getting a site assessment from NTL Storage

NTL Storage supplies and installs longspan shelving and mezzanine systems across Singapore, and has worked on racking and platform projects since 2012. Send us your unit’s internal clear height, floor area, permitted floor loading and what you store, and we will tell you whether shelving, a mezzanine or a mix fits the building before you commission any design work. If a mezzanine is the answer, we will also flag the slab and headroom questions your PE will ask first.

FAQs About Longspan Shelving vs Mezzanine

Is longspan shelving cheaper than a mezzanine?

Usually, yes. Longspan shelving is priced by the bay and needs no Professional Engineer, BCA submission or SCDF submission. A mezzanine adds structural steel, PE design and supervision, approval fees and sprinkler extension under the deck. It becomes better value only when you need usable floor area that shelving cannot provide.

Do I need approval to install longspan shelving in Singapore?

Freestanding longspan shelving needs no BCA or SCDF submission. In JTC premises it is exempt from JTC plan consent only up to 3.0 m high and 1.2 m wide, within 7.5 kN/m² gross weight. Shelving with raised walkways counts as an access platform and needs approval like a mezzanine.

Does a mezzanine floor need BCA approval?

Yes. A mezzanine is building work under the Building Control Act. A Professional Engineer must submit structural plans to BCA and obtain a permit before work starts, and SCDF must approve the fire safety works and issue a Fire Safety Certificate before the deck is used.

How much weight can longspan shelving hold per level?

Most longspan shelving holds 250 kg to 500 kg per level, with heavy duty versions up to about 800 kg. The rating applies per level at a stated beam span and assumes the load is spread across the deck. Longer spans carry less, so always ask for the rating at your exact span.

What ceiling height do I need for a mezzanine?

As a working rule, storage over storage rarely works below about 5.5 m of internal clear height, once deck depth, beams and sprinkler clearance are subtracted. Lower units usually do better with taller shelving or racking. A PE should confirm the headroom on a section drawing before design starts.

Can I put longspan shelving on a mezzanine floor?

Yes. It is a common way to create a second carton picking level. The PE must design the deck for the loaded shelving, not only foot traffic, and sprinkler coverage must reach the upper level. Declare the shelving layout at design stage rather than adding it after approval.

Comments are closed.